Showing posts with label teaching. Show all posts
Showing posts with label teaching. Show all posts

Sunday, March 18, 2007

The dark side of standardized testing

One of my favorite webcomics is "Irregular Webcomic" by David Morgan-Mar. Today's comic struck my teacher's funny bone:



In his notes he says, "If you ever wonder about the eventual outcome of the modern trend of making sure children don't fail high school by making the passing grades low enough that they can all manage to scrape through, now you know. Someone, somewhere, decided that having kids fail looked bad, so to boost the statistics they lowered the standard rather than giving the teachers the resources and remuneration they deserve."

The full post is here:
http://www.irregularwebcomic.net/1512.html

I have to praise you like I should...

My husband and I both have personal journals at livejournal.com. Today he posted a link to this article in New York Magazine which discusses the merits of praising children. In short, it says praising children for their effort is much more effective than lauding them for being smart.

The principal at my school is constantly telling us to "flood the students with praise," but has never been this specific about what kind of praise. However, I always tell my students that I grade them based on effort rather than how attractive their artwork is. I'm much more impressed by a student who works hard than one who has "natural talent."

Saturday, March 17, 2007

NAEA conference, day 2

Between packing and dragging my luggage across Manhattan, I didn’t make it to see Daniel Pink at 9am, which was my intention. I’ll have to pick up his book and read it. I arrived at the conference at 9:45, dropped off my bags and got swept into the exhibit halls with the crowd of freebie-crazed art teachers. I spent an hour wandering around and getting seconds of my favorite freebies from yesterday. I couldn’t find the rolling suitcase vendor I was looking for, but I did run into the MassArt rep that I know. I chatted with her for a while because I wanted to find out what I could do to help one of my students get in. (He’s really terrific: does graffiti, tattoos, and wonderful drawings with a very distinct style. He takes any material I throw at him and makes something gorgeous and distinctive.)

While we were chatting, another MA teacher wandered up and made some inquiries about her son’s prospects. She mentioned that he was also looking at Hampshire and Bard Colleges, and my friend said “I went to Hampshire!” I chimed in that I had been there too (though it was 20 years later) and the three of us spent a while talking about colleges. The teacher/mother and I ended up wandering off to the Edible Art presentation together, chatting about local art schools on our way.

The presentation was given by two MA teachers, both of whom I know well. It was a very useful set of instructions on how to set up your own Edible Art Contest. It contained some of the most useful content I’d seen at the conference, and I made sure to tell them that. I think it would be fun to do, but I’m not sure it would work at my school. Only a few kids would participate, and the others would just want to eat the art. I once held a pumpkin contest with K-8 students, and a lot of the techniques they suggested, like giving superlatives (“most creative”) instead of 1st place, etc, are things that I did. It made me feel like I’m using good teaching practices, especially since one presenter was the former MAEA president, and the other was the current one!

Unfortunately, it was the last session I attended. The next batch wasn’t until 2pm, and I wanted to be on a 2:20 bus. I hugged my friends, packed up my stuff, and headed for Port Authority…and my 8-hour trip home is a tale for another blog, another time.

Friday, March 16, 2007

Segregation?

I got an alumni update email from Tufts, and was disappointed to find that I had missed a lecture by the educator and social activist Jonathan Kozol. I read my first book of his, There are no Children Here when I was taking a class entitled "The Child and the City" back at Hampshire in about 1994. The class was about the plight of the urban children, and was one of my first education classes.

Kozol's lecture at Tufts addressed the topic “Still Separate, Still Unequal: The Continuing Decapitation of Potential in America’s Apartheid Schools.” He makes a strong case for calling out US schools for continuing to segregate.

As a public school teacher in an urban district, working primarily with "at-risk" students, I have to say I agree that there still is segregation, though it is not solely based on race. It is, however very clearly socioeconomic. My school is not the "dumping grounds for poor black boys" that the district fears it is or will be, but it is almost entirely non-white, and almost entirely poor students. And our faculty is mostly educated, white women. It does make you think.

The article about Kozol's talk is here: Public shame:The way America pays for education puts a price tag on our kids’ heads.

Thursday, March 15, 2007

NAEA Conference

I am attending the National Art Education Association conference in New York. Today I spent the morning in the exhibition halls, being plied with free goodies from vendors in the hopes that I will order their products for my classroom. In the afternoon I attended some presentations.

The first was a session on teaching 3D arts at the elementary level. All of the lessons were designed to be completed in 1-2 45-minute sessions. This is ideal for schools where you meet with your students once a week for 12 weeks, or if you are "art on the cart." I wish this presentation had been longer, because I would have liked to see their k-5 lessons in more detail. Fortunately, I have an email address to request a copy of the powerpoint presentation.

The next was, in theory, a presentation on "discussing controversial issues/art with children" but was a poorly organized lecture at best. The presenters were university instructors. They showed a bunch of controversial images out of context, discussed how their art ed students had come up with a list of potential lessons and hypothetical tactics for dealing with reluctant parents and administrators, and then focused on a single anecdotal experience when supporting the display of a college student's painting of a nude woman with her hand over her genitals (entitled "Women Have Balls, Too) against complaints from other college students. I know college students are young, but they are NOT children, and this presentation was not at all useful.

Finally, there was a presentation by two MAEA people that I know: the former MAEA president, and one of my cooperating teachers from my student teaching in Winthrop. They spent 1/2 an hour talking about how they put together a display of postcards from students across Massachusetts, using clear pocketed shower curtains that hold 4x6 index cards. The display method really is cool, but didn't need to be discussed for 30 minutes. It was a tad overkill. The best piece of info I got was where to obtain those shower curtains.

The biggest problem I had all day was the same as last year in Chicago: the conference rooms are too small. I couldn't get into some rooms, and the one room I did get into I never left because it took me an hour to get in and finally get a seat. So I just stayed put and waited to see what presenter would show up next. All in all, I didn't do too badly with that method: 2 out of 3 ain't bad.

After the presentations, I stopped at a social gathering and joined a tableful of teachers from all over the country. We chatted for a while and I got some advice on my job search, some much needed moral support, and a little bit of teachertalk. With some refreshments to sustain me, I felt ready to hit a few more presentations. By happy accident, I ended up in a Museum Educators' session about summer camp programs at the Taft Museum in Cincinatti, which has an interesting way of including collections acquisition for their elementary art camp attendees. One of their lessons asked the question "What objects define your culture, family, etc." The idea was to have a collection of items, like urns represent a period Greek history. They expected the kids to bring in iPods and cell phones, but instead got photos of family and friends. It was an unexpected surprise.

Then I went to another presentation by a teacher who works with middle school students to create "collaborative collage mandalas" that are influenced by 9/11. That was really interesting, and I think I'd like to try his lesson: What do you want the world to look like by 2020? Start with yourself and work outward to family, community, etc. He also said he has 90 minute blocks with his middle schoolers, which really surprised me.

All in all, my one full day at the conference was pretty productive. Tomorrow I get to spend a few more hours, and then I must go home. But already it was worth the bus ride here and back.

Monday, May 01, 2006

Painting Ceiling Tiles

I've been a member of a community called 1st_year_teachers on livejournal.com since I was a first year teacher. Another member, whyintellectual, is a high school art teacher in Florida. She did this great project where she had students paint ceiling tiles in her classroom. It even got written up in a local paper. I wanted to do it at my school, but couldn't get permission from my administration. Maybe the next school will let me do it.


Her post about it.